View
Abstract
Most governments are mandated to maintain their economies at full employment. We propose that the best marker of full employment is the efficient unemployment rate, $u^\ast$, which is the unemployment rate that minimizes the nonproductive use of labor—both unemployment and recruiting. The nonproductive use of labor is well measured by the number of jobseekers and vacancies, $u + v$. Through the Beveridge curve, the number of vacancies is inversely related to the number of jobseekers. With such symmetry, the labor market is efficient when there are as many jobseekers as vacancies ($u = v$), too tight when there are more vacancies than jobseekers ($v > u$), and too slack when there are more jobseekers than vacancies ($u > v$). Moreover, the efficient unemployment rate is the geometric average of the unemployment and vacancy rates: $u^\ast = \sqrt{uv}$. We compute $u^\ast$ for the United States between 1930 and 2022. We find that $u^\ast$ averages 4.1% over the period, that $u^\ast$ is quite stable over time and, for instance, that the US labor market was inefficiently tight from the middle of 2021 to the end of 2022.
Figure 12: Unemployment rate, vacancy rate, and efficient unemployment rate in the United States, 1930–2022
Citation
Michaillat, Pascal, and Emmanuel Saez. 2023. “$u^\ast = \sqrt{uv}$.” arXiv:2206.13012. https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2206.13012 .
@unpublished{MS23,
author = {Pascal Michaillat and Emmanuel Saez},
doi = {10.48550/arXiv.2206.13012},
note = {arXiv:2206.13012},
title = {$u^\ast = \sqrt{uv}},
year = {2023}}
Related material
- Slides for short presentation
- Slides for regular presentation
- Slides for extended presentation – This presentation includes evidence of divine coincidence in the United States, and shows that the divine coincidence appears in a simple monetary model with unemployment.
- The Fake Problem of Fake Vacancies – This Substack post argues that recent critisms of vacancy data and their use by the Federal Reserve are unwarranted. These criticisms have no solid empirical or theoretical basis. There is a lot to learn from vacancy data, as this paper shows, and it is a good thing that the Fed is using them to inform policy.
- Figuring Out Efficient Unemployment – This VoxEU column summarizes the paper’s theory and computes the efficient unemployment rate in the recovery from the coronavirus pandemic.